Meet Moses Reaper, the evil Halloween twin to Jasper Hill Farm’s classic Moses Sleeper. This seasonal, soft-ripened cheese trades the original’s familiar look for a delightfully spooky makeover, with dark vegetable ash cutting through an orange-tinted paste colored with annatto. Made from pasteurized cow’s milk and aged with traditional cultures, Moses Reaper develops a soft, creamy texture beneath its bloomy rind. Sinister in appearance but devilishly delicious, it’s right at home on a Halloween cheese board—pair it with crisp apples, crusty bread, and all your favorite eerie-season accompaniments.

