Serves 4-6

This zesty mini pie will put a pep in your step. The perfectly crispy graham cracker crust supports a decadent layer of sweet-tart lime filling, optimally balanced with creaminess and zing. A generous blanket of whipped cream rests atop sprinkled with fresh lime zest.


Packaged in a tin foil container and topped with Cait's key lime signature green smiley face logo.

Follow @caitskeylime on IG and find more info on her website.

Image from Farm to People
Cait's Key LimeCait's Key Lime

Brooklyn, NY

Much like the sourdough bakers and the puzzlers, Caitlin started perfecting her Key Lime Pie recipe as a pandemic hobby. Once she struck the perfect balance between sweet, tart, and creamy and landed on the ultimate golden graham cracker crust, she started selling her personal pies at pop-ups around the city! Now, Cait’s pies can be ordered for pick-up or delivery, and at select local restaurants around the area – and for a limited time, on our website!


Follow @caitskeylime on IG and find more info on her website.